Pride goes before a fall. People love humble men, the gods always do good to them. And the world is the moral science studies version of utopia where the cheat is always punished and the honest boy given top marks.
I know a lot of young people that are in that important cusp of life where they have to make career choices, and horror of horrors, get enrolled into choice colleges. So much of my conversation in the past couple of months have been about interviews, CV writing and the paraphernalia that go with it.
And through those conversations, I realized how Indians have an inherent manner of discrediting themselves, or, at least downplaying their achievements (yours truly not exempt from the allegation). It stems from very old traditions and cultural practices that teach how it is not for men to tell others what their achievements are, it is for others to notice. Clearly, they hadn't yet dealt with private firms and bad bosses.
The premise of those teachings, like all things old and Indian, are very correct, based on the notion that if you do good work, people are bound to take note. But like all things old and Indian, no one has bothered to adapt them to fit into today's life, leaving a generation that either suffers from internal conflict and lose out on jobs because they can't sell themselves right, or go the absolute other way and turn into wind bags that could cause the equivalent of atomic explosions.
Pride, for most Indians, comes mixed with negativity, often confused with snootiness, disdain or worse, rudeness.
Pride, if looked upon as a quality in itself, is not necessarily any of those, and when exercised in the right way has the magical way of boosting people's moral and even uplifting careers. I am a wordly girl, and I'm not going to go all esoteric on you. Boosting. Career. You read it right.
The Oxford English describes pride as "a feeling of deep pleasure or satisfaction derived from one’s own achievements, the achievements of one’s close associates, or from qualities or possessions that are widely admired." Also a pack of lions, but that is not what this post is about.
I hear the phrase "xyz makes America a great country" thrown into so many daily conversations in real life or on TV, see so many houses proudly host the national flag in their yards, so many bikini clad women wear the stars and stripes happily on the beach it is difficult not be effected by the enthusiasm. I'm not saying hot Indian women should start parading the beach in the Indian tricolor, there is a cultural roadblock to it that does not need to be altered at all.
But in my years of living in various Indian cities and towns, I have not seen one private residence that has a regular fixture for the national flag. Now that I think about it, I can't even recall any big mounting or presence of the tricolor in even the new, jazzy, international airport at New Delhi. That airport also does not have a bookstore, though it has a Chanel store I think. It naturally devastated me and upset my travel plans a bit, mostly because I can't afford to buy Chanel off the cuff, but then to be fair, when did the world promise me no devastation or upsets?
In retrospect, for every genuine "I love my country and I am proud of its rich and varied heritage" I've heard, the sarcasm and belittling has exceeded it by ten fold, with the intellenstia having sought refuge to the all encompassing "what can we do? This decline can't be helped." Of course it can't, because no one, including you, is doing anything about it. And when I say you, I mean you, unless you are doing something about it. Which I very much doubt.
We love to live in a bubble of inverted understanding where not reading or knowing about the Mahabharata or Gita is decidedly cool, though one can read the Iliad or Odyssey. Or wait, not read at all. Who needs books when you can buy clothes, right?
We will not learn about politics or economics from Chanakya, but we will pay a lot of money for subscriptions to the Wall Street Journal or The Economist, we will not practice or experiment with sex like they did in the days of Vyasdev or Kalidas, but we will watch Sunny Leone and Kim Kardashian on T.V.
And lotus eaters that we are, not knowing the gayatri mantra or the national pledge is totally ok with us, though we can recognise strains of the "The star spangled banner" from 50 feet away. The star what, did you ask? Oh well.
Also, I am not ready to tow your line if you say "but I am proud, I just don't show it."
Here's why. Once upon a time, a diffident young girl had asked the monk who frequented her house why it was necessary to worship god at all if He was everywhere anyway. The monk asked her if she had a boyfriend or had a crush. The wise man then said, like all relationships we build with other men, the relationship we build with god is also a two way traffic. It needs nurturing, and it needs some external manifestation to let the other party know you are interested. "If you just keep the fact that you like this guy to yourself, will you ever have a relationship? How will he ever know, and how will he ever get a chance to reciprocate? We all need to express ourselves, more for our sakes than for others."
I've never forgotten that reply, and though I won't claim to have followed it to the T always, I know from personal experience that I've been better off when I have. God, country, boyfriend, teacher, friend, spouse: all relationships and bonds need attention and some outward show of affection at some point. Unless you are Bruce Almighty and can communicate directly with the powers that be. But look how that turned out!
Moral fibre, that will-o-the wispy stuff that differentiates real men from the multitude, often goes hand in hand with a sense of knowing and being comfortable with oneself, which in turn comes from a sense of pride in one's achievements. Or so one hopes. If you are a latent wife beater/rapist/cheat/murderer, none of this applies to you. (I am hoping no active any of those mentioned is reading this post).
One does not really need to compare countries and continents to see the difference.
I felt it the most when I was graduating. I can proudly say the college I attended is still counted (like it has been for the past 100 years I think) among the 10 best colleges in India. Note: there is justification that goes along with pride. In India, where millions graduate each year, it is not an easy job finding a place in the college of your choice. Or finding a place at all, for that matter, unless you can buy your way in, of course.
I've been to three different educational institutions, but till this day, when someone asks me "where did you study", I say I graduated from this college. One reason for that is that graduation is the most relevant while judging a person's education in India; anything you did before that is too insignificant and anything beyond too erudite.
But I suspect the real reson is that that was the one instutute which drilled into me a sense of pride of being associated with it. I can see that pattern repeated in countless other students from other similar esteemed schools and colleges. There is often resulting cockiness; the by-product that makes it a dangerous proposition, but the confidence does the kids a world of good. It is a deciding factor in many a group discussion and interview where these "smart" kids talk their way to the coveted colleges or jobs, while others flounder.
I now see the same pattern repeated later in life, where "docile Asians" have complained about being pushed over by "more aggressive Americans". Asians (I can and do vouch for Indians at least) can and often are as aggresive and volatile as Americans if need be . But Indians are yet to shake off their colonial hangover entirely-- everyone from Gandhi to Mark Tully will side with me on this-- so we lose half the battle in our minds because we are yet to feel decidedly confident about who we are and what we can achieve. Nevermind countless examples to prove the fact. And till we do that, we will never be truly proud of who we are. Not the MBA'd executive, not the H1B visa holder, nor the server at Cafe Mondegar who will categorically give you the cold shoulder till his white guests have been tended to.
Those of who are, face no trouble in navigating colleagues and others in any part of the world at any time.
I'm no big fan of her works, but Jane Austen, that self styled feminist that made so many of us drool over a certain Darcy, has a very lucid explanation of what consists pride and what does not. Vanity and pride are different things, though the words are often used synonymously. A person may be proud without being vain. Pride relates more to our opinion of ourselves; vanity, to what we would have others think of us," she says through the otherwise uninspiring character of Mary.
Be proud, not vain. Or if you are, be sure not to use this blog as an excuse.
Curious to know what triggered this blog. As always you write well.
ReplyDeleteThings I noticed here and there, Amith. :)
ReplyDeleteMy 20 cents (wish I could write as much I have to say..),
ReplyDeleteI will restrict my case to the Indian diaspora here in the United states. To your remark "I realized how Indians have an inherent manner of discrediting themselves, or, at least downplaying their achievements" I don't think its true; well at-least in most cases. I rather think its true the other way around and I say this having gone through the supremely commercialized process of applying for American universities for your masters or PHD's. We basically compile a big load of rubbish and project ourselves as almost being directly responsible for some real spectacular things back home. The same applies for their CV's. The problem arrives when it comes to delivering to the level of calibre that you have been speaking of all this while. This country really doesn't care a damn about where you are from and where you studied from as long as you can deliver. Don't get me wrong it does help your case if you are from the known reputed colleges of India but it can only take you little further.
Most of the biggest achievers from the Indian community here didn't make it big because of where they came from but for what they did after that. As you pointed out a lot of these virtues can be attributed to our cultural make-up. In India 9 out of 10 times your pedigree (inclusive of education, wealth and gene pool) precedes your name and fame.
On your observations of the use of flags here as compared to Swades, its a case of old habit. They just love their flags here... Chicago has one of its own too. Its one of the oldest way of showing authority and instigating borderline jingoism. The equivalent act in India is carried out when you have huge mobs vandalizing public property they have a flag to show which group they belong (Read: Shiv sena, RSS). One of the most hilarious trend that started few years back home to stir the patriotism among Indians was that they started playing the national anthems in multiplexes before every movie.
"I love my country and I am proud of its rich and varied heritage", I think you hit the nail in the head here. This hackneyed phrase stems from the fact that we have always been a hero worshipper, a herd at best and mob at worst, a bunch of hopeless souls waiting for a messiah. One doesn't have to show great acts of valour and sacrifice for their country to prove their loyalty and love, just simply do their duties honestly. Yes, we had Chanakya teaching us how to govern people. Yes, we had it all figured out how to spice up sex. Yes, we had the best of everything .. but long long ago and we don't have it anymore. Not that we have lost them but its impact and implications have little significance as they all are a function of time. It cannot be just a mere unfortunate incident that we have been ruled by so many different rulers in succession. It's the lack of collective identity. India is still 65 years old with a new identity and this identity has already been put to test with time. The rate at which India is growing collectively is nowhere close to the rate at which Indians are growing collectively. Its catching up.. but it still has lot to do. If it happens in our life time then great and we will have a new generation of Indians after that which will be as ignorant and apathetic as our counterpart Americans of this generation... and the circle continues.
1. I said we go to extremes on both ends.
ReplyDelete2. the little anecdote is my counter to "i love my country but i won' show it" if you love, or are proud, it will show
3. "doesn't have to show great acts of valour and sacrifice for their country to prove their loyalty and love, just simply do their duties honestly. " Most of us don't do either.
but I am happy you took the time to comment, and thanks for that. :)